Dog is Life/Jerusalem

You don't see rabbits being walked down the street (1)
And you don't see many cats on leads
Dogs pet dogs dogs rapacious wet dogs
Owner of dogs slow-witted dog owner
Owner of rabid dog saving fare for tunnel  (2)
Euro-dream of civil, civil liberation for dogs
Society secret society inevitable nightmare
Of drift dog pet dogs street bullshit
Dog shit baby bit ass-lick dog mirror
Dead tiger shot and checked out by dog
Big tea-chest-fucker dog
Black collar sends East German refugee back switch and crap pathetic (3)
Of earth-like lousy dog role model for infidel doghouse continent
Mutt citadel dog-eye mirror hypnotic school slaver and learn   (4)
Lot from dog on grass and over nervous delicate dog
Detracts light from indiscrepant non-dog-lover
Dog pet dog come home to ya
Come home we'll talk shit to ya
Dog the pet-owner-owner blistered hanging there death dog 
Plato of the human example and copier dogmaster pet mourner (5)
Dog is life

And did those feet in ancient times, (6)
Walk upon mountains green?
And was the holy Lamb of God,
On England's pleasant pastures seen?

And did the Countenance Divine,
Shine forth on clouded hills?
And was Jerusalem 
In the dark Satanic Mills? 

Jerusalem

It was the fault of the government  (7)
I was walking down the street (8)
When I tripped up on a discarded banana skin
And on my way down I caught the side of my head
On a protruding brick chip  (9)
It was the government's fault
It was the fault of the government
I was very let down with the budget
I was expecting a one million quid handout
I was very disappointed
It was the government's fault
It was the fault of the government

I became a semi-artistic type person
And I didn't have a pen
And I didn't have a condom
It was the fault of the government
I think I'll emigrate to Sweden or Poland
And get looked after properly by government

Jerusalem

Bring Bow of burning gold:
Bring Arrows of desire:
Bring me Spear: O clouds unfold!

And though I rest from Mental Fight  (10)
And though sword sleeps in hand
I will not rest til Jerusalem is built

In Englands green and pleasant Land.

 

Notes

1. MES reportedly hates dogs. From Mick Middles' The Fall:

"Mark E. Smith has a deep aversion to anything remotely canine. Always a ‘cat’ man, he once lingered for 20 minutes on the stairs of my house, playing cheerily with my two bemused black’n’white cats. 'Mick, your cats are boooootifoool.' Once, sitting in The Foresters Arms in Prestwich, a local toady Fall fan approached him with the words, 'It’s great that dog, isn’t it Mark?' to be swiftly rebuffed by Mark’s, 'No it fucking isn’t … it’s the worst thing about this pub, that fucking filthy dog … wish they would get rid of it and get a cat!'" ['Sic' throughout!]

It is easy to credit the veracity of such reports, in light of the following lyrics.

"A dog is for life, not just for Christmas" is a well-known campaign phrase used by the National Canine Defence League ("Dog's Trust" since 2003) since about 1979ish (Dan).

The other obvious reference is "God is life." 'Dog' is of course 'God' backwards; the more common phrase would be the Christian "Jesus is Life," a slogan which derives from the statements attributed to Jesus in the Bible "I am the resurrection and the life" (John 11:25), and "I am the way, the truth, and the life" (John 14:6). See note 4 below.

Note the possible resonance with George Clinton's "Atomic Dog," which proclaims: "These are clapping dogs, rhythmic dogs, harmonic dogs, house dogs, street dogs/Dogs of the world unite; dancin dogs, yeah, countin' dogs, funky dogs, nasty dogs!" Dan reports that this was pointed out in the article "Sound-alikes" in the Fall fanzine The Biggest Library Yet (issue 7, September 1996).

From Dan:

From Hot Dogs in the Far Out Zone, by MES. NME, 30 July 1988, pp.14-15:
 

HOLLAND

On arrival write vicious anti-dog rant, although I haven't seen one in ages. What actually sparks it off was hearing English cricket commentary on hotel's TV. This was depressing after bliss of six weeks of TV in foreign languages, where you can make it up yourself.



And Rob points out that the title is an allusion to Opus's "Live is Life"; on I Am as Pure as Oranj, MES sings the "na na, na na na" refrain right before the transition to "Jerusalem," which nicely foreshadows the latter's riff. 

^

2.Dan drops some Chunnel science:

Construction of the Channel Tunnel commenced in 1988, and would be opened in 1994. There were widely published fears in the late 1980s that the Tunnel would let rabies into Britain. And dog licences had been abolished in 1987.

For example, see the Daily Mail of 6 October 1987: "Stray dogs are rabies 'time-bomb'" (p.13):
 


Up to a million stray dogs roaming Britain's streets are 'rabies time-bombs' which could plunge the country into catastrophe, animal experts warned yesterday.

Increased traffic between Britain and Europe - helped by the Channel Tunnel - means there is bound to be an outbreak of the deadly disease, says the RSPCA. 

The grim prediction came as the society launched a campaign against Government plans to scrap dog licenses.
 

^

3.A probable reference to guard dogs at the Berlin Wall (thanks, Dan).

^

4. Thanks to Rob pointing out the allusion to Pavlov and what is now known as "classical (as opposed to 'operant') conditioning." 

^

5. In the Republic, Plato likens the guardians of the city to watchdogs. In the Victorian era, a faithful dog that has lost its master is sometimes portrayed in paintings that have been referred to as "dog mourner" paintings. Plato is often thought to have seen the physical world as a copy of an ideal world of Forms ("often thought" because there are debates in Plato scholarship about this, but in any case it is a hypothesis that is treated in the dialogues). 

Note also again here the inversion "dog::god." The dog "blistered hanging there" can also be seen as a image of the crucified Christ, who in the traditional hierarchy of things would in a sense be the "pet owner owner." The Platonic god, a type of what is sometimes called "the god of the philosophers," is inverted by the notion of god-as-human-as-dog. Note that William Blake, the ultimate source of the Jerusalem lyrics, saw the human form as the highest way to understand god, an inversion of the philosophers' conception of god which in whatever form generally takes anthropocentric notions of divinity as a mythological approximation to the truth. And "Dog is Life" is inverted here as the "death dog"...

^

6. Most of the following lines are taken from William Blake. They appear in the preface to Blake's lengthy "prophetic" work, Milton a Poem. Blake's verse gets chopped up a bit in the process; the original lines are as follows:

And did those feet in ancient time.
Walk upon Englands mountains green:
And was the holy Lamb of God,
On Englands pleasant pastures seen!

And did the Countenance Divine,
Shine forth upon our clouded hills?
And was Jerusalem builded here,
Among these dark Satanic Mills?

Bring me my Bow of burning gold;
Bring me my Arrows of desire:
Bring me my Spear: O clouds unfold!
Bring me my Chariot of fire!

I will not cease from Mental Fight,
Nor shall my Sword sleep in my hand:
Till we have built Jerusalem,
In Englands green & pleasant Land

This section of Milton was famously set to music by Sir Hubert Parry in 1916 as a hymn called "Jerusalem." The Fall's version has a melody that is simpler, yet somewhat similar, to the hymn. Emerson, Lake & Palmer recorded a version of the hymn in 1973 on Brain Salad Surgery, and Jonder points out that Blake's poem was first set in a post-punk musical context by Mark Stewart and Maffia on their 1982 single Jerusalem.

Courtesy of mountainoaf:

From an interview with Liz Kershaw on Radio One, circa "Kurious Oranj": LK: Now, it's rumoured that you're doing a cover of Jerusalem. MES: That starts the show off. LK: You've actually done it. So how do you do that, 'cause it was our school song, do you give it a totally different interpretation? MES: It was your school song... well, I think it was everyone's school song. We approach it like the Velvet Underground would. There's a nice joke section in the middle of it as well.

"Jerusalem" is technically a distinct song from "Dog is Life," and they have been performed separately.  

Harley has dug up some apposite comments from MES:

Been doing some clearing out and I came across this snippet on a xerox sent (I think) by the Fall fan club back in the day... original capitalisation and punctuation preserved.

HAVE YOU SEEN THE ORIGINAL OF BLAKES 'MILTON'? THEY BROUGHT IT OUT. IT'S INCREDIBLE. IT'S JUST LIKE YOU WERE SAYING. THE PREFACE IS 'JERUSALEM'. THERE'S THIS BIG RAP ABOUT HOW CRAP GREEK ART IS AND HOW BRITAIN'S GOT TO GET IT'S SHIT TOGETHER THEN THERE'S 'JERUSALEM' THEN THERE'S THE POEM. BUT IT MUST'VE TOOK HIM AGES COS EVERY PAGE IS ART WITH HANDWRITING OVER IT. I'VE SEEN NOTHING LIKE IT IN MY LIFE. APPARENTLY HE HAD TO DO IT ALL BACKWARDS SO IT COULD BE PRINTED UP. YOU GET 'JERUSALEM', YOU READ IT IN A BOOK AND IT'S OKAY BUT IN THE ORIGINAL IT'S JUST THIS FUCKING RAP, DEAD CONCENTRATED LIKE, THEN THE POEM BUT UNDERNEATH THERE'S THESE RAINBOWS AND TYPICAL BLAKE STUFF AND AS IT GOES ON THERE'S LANDSCAPES AND STONEHENGE. YOU CAN'T READ THE POEM CAUSE OF ALL THIS GREAT ART BEHIND IT. WITH BLAKE I TEND TO JUST READ BITS OUT OF IT AND JUST MEDIDATE ON IT. I THINK THAT'S THE BEST WAY TO TREAT HIM BUT WITH THIS IT'S LIKE TOTALLY DIFFERENT. WHAT AMAZED ME WAS IN THIS BOOK IN THE RAP HE GOES ON ABOUT HOW FULL OF CRAP PLATO IS AND ALL THAT AND THAT'S WHAT I WAS SAYING IN THAT 'DOG IS LIFE' THING AND I'D NEVER ACTUALLY READ THE PREFACE.

I THOUGHT THAT WAS QUITE A COINCIDENCE.

And from Dan:

Sounds,  5 November 1988:  
 

Oh, I'm a complete William Blake fan, always have been. Someone gave me the original book, and the rap before it is brilliant.

"It's funny, cos in this poem before 'Jerusalem' I'm going on about Plato and how crap it is, and in the book Blake wrote, Milton, the preface has this rap about how we should cast off all these stupid Roman and Greek ideals and build the new art. He goes on about Plato being perverted and that."

See "More Information" below for the full text of Blake's preface to Milton.

^

7. Dan:

For the left and the labour movement, "building Jerusalem" has a radical meaning; it's about establishing socialism. For the right, they see it in nationalistic and conservative terms.

Either way, this song ironically contrasts the transcendent utopianism of Blake's poem, and the petty whinging he hears in his local pub, or from fellow artists. Visionary politics has been replaced by nanny statism and self-interest and entitlement. Now it's not unreasonable to see that, in the context of the time, and given the "the government should look after me" content, and MES's frequently expressed anti-socialism (derived more from betrayals by socialists, perhaps, rather than a rejection of progressive working class politics per se, but who knows), as targeting the left. But it's not necessarily so - such sentiments are common across the spectrum.

Anyway, none of that is uniquely insightful. In terms of a note, I think it's just about flagging the irony and identifying Jerusalem's political meanings.

^

8. This is a favorite line of MES's, who also uses it in "Blindness" and "Ol' Gang," and variants pop up elsewhere.The following anecdote is told by Stewart Lee about seeing comedian Ted Chippington open for the Fall:

Ted took the stage to a crowd that weren't expecting him, rooted to the spot in Teddy Boy regalia, scowling and supping a beer. He spent half an hour delivering variations on the same joke, each of which began with the phrase "I was walking down this road the other day," in a flat Midlands monotone, interspersed with listless interpretations of pop hits. A typical joke would run like this "I was walking down the road the other day, this chap came up to me. I said to him, 'Haven't seen you for a while.' He said 'Well, I've just got back from Nam.' I said, 'What, you mean Vietnam?' He said 'No, mate, Chelt'nam.'"

According to Lee this happened on October 28th, 1984, at a place in Birmingham called the Powerhouse. The gigography confirms this date and time, and various sources on the web mention Chippington opening for the Fall. Anyway, it's possible MES's frequent use of the line is a kind of homage to Chippington.

On the other hand, purple_prince remarks: "It seems too much of a coincidence for there not to be a connection to the countless folk songs that begin with a variant of 'As I walked/rode out one May morning' as an introduction to the tale. It seems to connect the Fall - if obliquely - to the folk tradition. This connection is not as remote as it sounds really if you think of Smith as the skewed working-class balladeer and some of the ancient ballads are full of strange imagery." I think he is absolutely correct to identify a link to folk balladry in MES's lyrics, an idea which should be explored in more detail.

^

 

 

9. Hexen Blumenthal submits this, which is worth including in full. From H P Lovecraft's TS Eliot parody “Waste Paper: A Poem of Profound Insignificance”:

Bootleggers all and you’re another
In the shade of the old apple tree
’Neath the old cherry tree sweet Marie
The Conchologist’s First Book
By Edgar Allan Poe
Stubbed his toe
On a broken brick that didn’t shew
Or a banana peel
In the fifth reel
By George Creel
It is to laugh
And quaff

^

10. Blake has "I will not cease from mental fight" (see note 3 above).

^

More Information

Dog is Life: Fall Tracks A-Z

Jerusalem: Fall Tracks A-Z

The Story of the Fall: 1988

 

William Blake's preface to Milton:

PREFACE

THE Stolen and Perverted Writings of Homer & Ovid, of Plato & Cicero, which all Men ought to contemn, are set up by artifice against the Sublime of the Bible; but, when the New Age is at leisure to Pronounce, all will be set right, & those Grand Works of the more ancient & consciously & professedly Inspired Men will hold their proper rank, & the Daughters of Memory shall become the Daughters of Inspiration. Shakspeare & Milton were both curb'd by the general malady & infection from the silly Greek & Latin slaves of the Sword. Rouze up, O Young Men of the New Age! Set your foreheads against the ignorant Hirelings! For we have Hirelings in the Camp, the Court & the University, who would, if they could, forever depress Mental & prolong Corporeal War. Painters, on you I call! Sculptors! Architects! Suffer not the fashionable Fools to depress your powers by the prices they pretend to give for contemptible works or the expensive advertizing boasts that they make of such works; believe Christ & his Apostles that there is a Class of Men whose whole delight is in Destroying. We do not want either Greek or Roman Models if we are but just & true to our own Imaginations, those Worlds of Eternity in which we shall live forever in Jesus our Lord.

 

Comments (64)

Zack
  • 1. Zack (link) | 26/08/2013
"Dog is Life" is almost certainly the "vicious anti-dog rant" that MES mentioned writing in Holland in his 1988 tour journal.
Martin
  • 2. Martin | 09/09/2013
As for the references to the budget in the song, it may of interest that the UK 1988 budget, delivered by Nigel Lawson, was on 15 March, less than a month before the song debuted in concert. According to wiki:

"During the 1988 budget statement of Chancellor of the Exchequer Nigel Lawson, Labour MP Dave Nellist led a group who attempted to intervene and disrupt the sitting; he refused to resume his seat. The Speaker suspended the sitting for 10 minutes."
Mark
  • 3. Mark | 03/07/2014
From an interview with Liz Kershaw on Radio One, circa "Kurious Oranj":

LK: Now, it's rumoured that you're doing a cover of Jerusalem.
MES: That starts the show off.
LK: You've actually done it. So how do you do that, 'cause it was our school song, do you give it a totally different interpretation?
MES: It was your school song... well, I think it was everyone's school song. We approach it like the Velvet Underground would. There's a nice joke section in the middle of it as well.
Alan
  • 4. Alan | 25/09/2016
The version on I Am As Pure As Oranj appears to be the same reading, but with an extra 8 lines or so between lines 4 & 5 as published above. Sorry, I haven't attempted to transcribe them yet
bzfgt
  • 5. bzfgt | 15/10/2016
Thanks Alan, and I will appreciate it if you do so. If not, someone will get to it eventually...I don't actually have that recording at the moment.
harleyr
  • 6. harleyr | 07/12/2016
I found the transcribed lyrics above a revelation but I think it's 'learn lot from dog' not 'rot'.
bzfgt
  • 7. bzfgt | 27/12/2016
That makes more sense, Harley. It's distorted at that point but it does sound that way to me so I changed it.
dannyno
  • 8. dannyno | 15/02/2017
"Owner of rabid dog saving fare for tunnel
Euro-dream of civil, civil liberation for dogs"

Construction of the Channel Tunnel commenced in 1988, and would be opened in 1994. There were widely published fears in the late 1980s that the Tunnel would let rabies into Britain. And dog licences had been abolished in 1987.

For example, see the Daily Mail of 6 October 1987: "Stray dogs are rabies 'time-bomb'" (p.13):


Up to a million stray dogs roaming Britain's streets are 'rabies time-bombs' which could plunge the country into catastrophe, animal experts warned yesterday.

Increased traffic between Britain and Europe - helped by the Channel Tunnel - means there is bound to be an outbreak of the deadly disease, says the RSPCA.

The grim prediction came as the society launched a campaign against Government plans to scrap dog licenses.

etc

dannyno
  • 9. dannyno | 15/02/2017
"Dog is life"

"A dog is for life, not just for Christmas" is a well-known campaign phrase used by the Dog's Trust since about 1979ish.
dannyno
  • 10. dannyno | 15/02/2017
"The Dog's Trust" was known as the National Canine Defence League until 2003.
dannyno
  • 11. dannyno | 15/02/2017
"Black collar sends East German refugee back"

A reference to the dogs guarding the Berlin Wall?
http://blog.gudog.co.uk/dogs-berlin-wall/
dannyno
  • 12. dannyno | 16/02/2017
"Dead tiger shot and checked out by dog"

There are contemporary press reports about the shooting of a tiger that escaped from Woburn Safari Park. I haven't, however, found anything describing the role of any dogs.

From The Times, 5 September 1987:


Two tigers escaped from their cages at Woburn Safari Park in Bedfordshire yesterday after a keeper forgot to close a door. One was caught but the second became restless and was shot dead.
bzfgt
  • 13. bzfgt | 18/02/2017
Well, I have the CD and he says "And did those streets in ancient times...
bzfgt
  • 14. bzfgt | 18/02/2017
"Plato of the human example and copier dogmaster pet mourner"

I have a number there. Either I had a note there and accidentally deleted while rearranging things just now, or there was an empty note, but fuck, I'd love to see what I had for that if I had something! It's gone now either way, and I have to come up with something (it seems like a note is definitely called for there).
dannyno
  • 15. dannyno | 28/02/2017
Your note numbering is a bit out of whack.

You have two note twos, the second of which says "2. In the Republic, Plato likens the guardians of the city to watchdogs." The ^ link from the note actually takes you to the Plato line in the song, which is numbered 4, and which takes you to your new note 4.
bzfgt
  • 16. bzfgt (link) | 03/03/2017
Thank you very much for pointing that out.
harleyr
  • 17. harleyr | 15/04/2017
Been doing some clearing out and I came across this snippet on a xerox sent (I think) by the Fall fan club back in the day... original capitalisation and punctuation preserved.

I thought Brix's illustrations in that German lyric book were very like William Blakes stuff, very dark like Dantes inferno or something...

HAVE YOU SEEN THE ORIGINAL OF BLAKES 'MILTON'? THEY BROUGHT IT OUT. IT'S INCREDIBLE. IT'S JUST LIKE YOU WERE SAYING. THE PREFACE IS 'JERUSALEM'. THERE'S THIS BIG RAP ABOUT HOW CRAP GREEK ART IS AND HOW BRITAIN'S GOT TO GET IT'S SHIT TOGETHER THEN THERE'S 'JERUSALEM' THEN THERE'S THE POEM. BUT IT MUST'VE TOOK HIM AGES COS EVERY PAGE IS ART WITH HANDWRITING OVER IT. I'VE SEEN NOTHING LIKE IT IN MY LIFE. APPARENTLY HE HAD TO DO IT ALL BACKWARDS SO IT COULD BE PRINTED UP. YOU GET 'JERUSALEM', YOU READ IT IN A BOOK AND IT'S OKAY BUT IN THE ORIGINAL IT'S JUST THIS FUCKING RAP, DEAD CONCENTRATED LIKE, THEN THE POEM BUT UNDERNEATH THERE'S THESE RAINBOWS AND TYPICAL BLAKE STUFF AND AS IT GOES ON THERE'S LANDSCAPES AND STONEHENGE. YOU CAN'T READ THE POEM CAUSE OF ALL THIS GREAT ART BEHIND IT. WITH BLAKE I TEND TO JUST READ BITS OUT OF IT AND JUST MEDIDATE ON IT. I THINK THAT'S THE BEST WAY TO TREAT HIM BUT WITH THIS IT'S LIKE TOTALLY DIFFERENT. WHAT AMAZED ME WAS IN THIS BOOK IN THE RAP HE GOES ON ABOUT HOW FULL OF CRAP PLATO IS AND ALL THAT AND THAT'S WHAT I WAS SAYING IN THAT 'DOG IS LIFE' THING AND I'D NEVER ACTUALLY READ THE PREFACE.

I THOUGHT THAT WAS QUITE A COINCIDENCE.

PREFACE

THE Stolen and Perverted Writings of Homer & Ovid, of Plato & Cicero, which all Men ought to contemn, are set up by artifice against the Sublime of the Bible; but, when the New Age is at leisure to Pronounce, all will be set right, & those Grand Works of the more ancient & consciously & professedly Inspired Men will hold their proper rank, & the Daughters of Memory shall become the Daughters of Inspiration. Shakspeare & Milton were both curb'd by the general malady & infection from the silly Greek & Latin slaves of the Sword. Rouze up, O Young Men of the New Age! Set your foreheads against the ignorant Hirelings! For we have Hirelings in the Camp, the Court & the University, who would, if they could, forever depress Mental & prolong Corporeal War. Painters, on you I call! Sculptors! Architects! Suffer not the fashionable Fools to depress your powers by the prices they pretend to give for contemptible works or the expensive advertizing boasts that they make of such works; believe Christ & his Apostles that there is a Class of Men whose whole delight is in Destroying. We do not want either Greek or Roman Models if we are but just & true to our own Imaginations, those Worlds of Eternity in which we shall live forever in Jesus our Lord.
dannyno
  • 18. dannyno | 16/04/2017
The illustrated texts are online here: http://www.blakearchive.org/

They've made it harder to link directly, so just quickly here's an example, from "Song of Liberty", which I used on the FOF in the Lyrical Magpie thread:

Image
bzfgt
  • 19. bzfgt (link) | 13/05/2017
Yeah I've got a book of all the illuminated texts. They are done by hand by engraving on a copper plate and then eroding the unillustrated parts with acid...
dannyno
  • 20. dannyno | 13/08/2017
The article "Sound-alikes" in Fall fanzine The Biggest Library Yet (issue 7, September 1996), suggests a George Clinton influence on "Dog is Life" - specifically "Atomic Dog" (1982).

There is certainly something of a lyrical echo - both songs make use of lists.


These are clapping dogs, rhythmic dogs
Harmonic dogs, house dogs, street dogs
Dog of the world unite - dancin dogs
Yeah, countin dogs, funky dogs
Nasty dogs
dannyno
  • 21. dannyno | 28/08/2017
Note 1: "MES reportedly hates dogs."

We should cite a source for this...
dannyno
  • 22. dannyno | 23/09/2017
MES on dogs.

From Renegade


Actually, I’m not such a big fan of dogs. I prefer cats.


and from a footnote in the Mick Middles/MES book "The Fall":


Mark E. Smith has a deep aversion to anything remotely canine. Always a ‘cat’ man, he once lingered for 20 minutes on the stairs of my house, playing cheerily with my two bemused black’n’white cats. “Mick, your cats are boooootifoool.” Once, sitting in The Foresters Arms in Prestwich, a local toady Fall fan approached him with the words, “It’s great that dog, isn’t it Mark?” to be swiftly rebuffed by Mark’s, “No it fucking isn’t … it’s the worst thing about this pub, that fucking filthy dog … wish they would get rid of it and get a cat!”
bzfgt
  • 23. bzfgt (link) | 07/10/2017
Great call with the Middles. In general, you must have noticed (and gritted your teeth), I'm a little lax with citing--if I'm sure something is true I don't always sweat it. I'm not saying that's justified. I think it's partly a result of frustration with the lifespan of links, now that you've given me the Wayback idea I may just up my standards. I haven't tried that yet, but it seems to be a great idea--if I were half the man I should be I'd start going through and converting everything.
bzfgt
  • 24. bzfgt (link) | 07/10/2017
Of course you're only a little better with your "a footnote"...
Jonder
  • 25. Jonder | 17/10/2017
It is worth noting that Blake's poem was first set in a post-punk musical context by Mark Stewart and Maffia on their 1982 single Jerusalem.
dannyno
  • 26. dannyno | 26/10/2017
bzfgt, comment #24.

Alright then, a footnote on p241 of the updated paperback edition (Omnibus Press, 2008).
bzfgt
  • 27. bzfgt (link) | 11/11/2017
Thank you, Jonder, I've noted it.
bzfgt
  • 28. bzfgt (link) | 10/02/2018
This is a major work and I/we need to study it more and add a little interpretation. I've added a little to notes 1 and 4 but the work has only begun here. I've bookmarked this in my "Annotation" folder so it will at least admonish me whenever I come here...
purple_prince
  • 29. purple_prince | 10/02/2018
On fn 6 "I was walking down the street". It seems too much of a coincidence for there not to be a connection to the countless folk songs that begin with a variant of 'As I walked/rode out one May morning" as an introduction to the tale. It seems to connect the Fall - if obliquely - to the folk tradition. This connection is not as remote as it sounds really if you think of Smith as the skewed working-class balladeer and some of the ancient ballads are full of strange imagery.
bzfgt
  • 30. bzfgt (link) | 17/02/2018
Good point, PP. You're a Hoffmanite, right? Welcome!
bzfgt
  • 31. bzfgt (link) | 17/02/2018
Also I have no doubt MES is connected, and sees himself being connected, to the folk tradition, and it has been remarked here more than once, I think (although the only example I can think of right now is one of the notes to "Loadstones"). Right you are.
grottyspawn
  • 32. grottyspawn | 21/02/2018
There was at least one dog MES liked, according to Liz Buckley of Ace Records:

The owner of the publishing company had an insanely cute but also just insane Jack Russell who would sit sweetly on my lap whilst I worked, only to break the idyll of office pet life to try and murder anyone that rang the doorbell, instantly attempting to leap through both my ribcage and sheet glass. He would bounce from floor to (their) neck-height, tongue-lolling, flattening his face against the spit-smeared glass until someone said, “okay, shush”. Mark E Smith was the only person I’ve ever seen visit that office unannounced, walk in and laughingly pat this loose cannon on the head without fear of nearly losing an arm, all whilst laughingly him a complete bastard. And I’m fairly sure the only reason he was left in tact was that unpredictable but never-not-funny dog recognised him as a pup from the same litter.
bzfgt
  • 33. bzfgt (link) | 24/02/2018
Great anecdote, grotty!
Hexen Blumenthal
  • 34. Hexen Blumenthal | 03/03/2018
From H P Lovecraft's (VERY MES-cog in parts) T S Eliot parody “Waste Paper: A Poem of Profound Insignificance.”

Bootleggers all and you’re another
In the shade of the old apple tree
’Neath the old cherry tree sweet Marie
The Conchologist’s First Book
By Edgar Allan Poe
Stubbed his toe
On a broken brick that didn’t shew
Or a banana peel
In the fifth reel
By George Creel
It is to laugh
And quaff
Rob
  • 35. Rob | 24/03/2018
The title Dog is Life is also a reference to the overblown euro-classic Live is Life by Opus. Mark would even sing the na-na-na-na-na refrain in live performance; this can be heard for instance on I am Pure as Oranj.

'Slaver and learn' is wonderful soundbite for the Nobel Prize-winning work of Ivan Pavlov on behavioural conditioning (in dogs).

And, for what it's worth, I hear "rot from dog on grass". I find this a much more compelling (albeit disgusting) image.
dannyno
  • 36. dannyno | 25/03/2018
Note #1. Seems like we overlooked this point.

From Hot Dogs in the Far Out Zone, by MES. NME, 30 July 1988, pp.14-15:

HOLLAND

On arrival write vicious anti-dog rant, although I haven't seen one in ages. What actually sparks it off was hearing English cricket commentary on hotel's TV. This was depressing after bliss of six weeks of TV in foreign languages, where you can make it up yourself.


http://thefall.org/gigography/88jul30.html
dannyno
  • 37. dannyno | 25/03/2018
Sorry, that should have referenced Zack's comment #1, not note #1.
dannyno
  • 38. dannyno | 25/03/2018
Should not this article:

Sounds, 5 November 1988: http://thefall.org/news/88nov05_sounds.txt

Oh, I'm a complete William Blake fan, always have been. Someone gave me the original book, and the rap before it is brilliant.

"It's funny, cos in this poem before 'Jerusalem' I'm going on about Plato and how crap it is, and in the book Blake wrote, Milton, the preface has this rap about how we should cast off all these stupid Roman and Greek ideals and build the new art. He goes on about Plato being perverted and that."
dannyno
  • 39. dannyno | 25/03/2018
Seems to be the source of the text in comment #17.
bzfgt
  • 40. bzfgt (link) | 07/04/2018
Excellent stuff, fellers!
bzfgt
  • 41. bzfgt (link) | 07/04/2018
Shit, how did I miss Harley's thing? It's cumbersome but I think I need to get it in.
dannyno
  • 42. dannyno | 28/01/2019
Note #1, I've followed up a bit more on MES' reference to writing an "anti-dog ramp" after hearing English cricket commentary on arrival in a hotel in the Netherlands. Or maybe not a Dutch hotel, it doesn't actually say that. Could have been one in Switzerland or Belgium.

Anyway, presumably we're talking April 1988 here, since that was when The Fall played some gigs in the Netherlands, and when the cricket season began.

So, if we assume MES is remembering accurately, what might the cricket commentary have been a commentary on?

It would be before the West Indian tour of England, where they played a sequence of one day internationals and tests against England over the summer (May through to August).

Perhaps the Sharjah Cup, which took place at the end of March 1988, with the final between India and New Zealand on 1st April.

Or the Pakistani cricket three-test tour of the West Indies, which began in early April and ended on 27 April. That last test was a 5 day match starting on 22nd April, so could be a candidate if there was English commentary.

Or one of the many county matches that started up in April?
dannyno
  • 43. dannyno | 28/01/2019
Sorry, typo in first sentence, should be "rant" not "ramp", obviously.
bzfgt
  • 44. bzfgt (link) | 16/02/2019
I love "Plato being perverted and that" which makes a slight hash of the original statement by implying an equivocal meaning of "perverted"...MES seems to often append "and that" when he's just said something intentionally dumb...
bzfgt
  • 45. bzfgt (link) | 16/02/2019
I can't believe there's yet another mystifying British sport...
Anselm
  • 46. Anselm | 09/04/2019
"And did those streets"? I'm not hearing that at all. It's "feet". I can see how the 's' sound of "those" merges a little into the next word, but I can still clearly hear the 'f'. And there's definitely no 's' at the end of the word, so unless he's saying "those street"...
bzfgt
  • 47. bzfgt (link) | 21/06/2019
I think you're right about "streets," that is much better (and Blake's original anyway)
dannyno
  • 48. dannyno | 22/06/2019
Dogs MES liked: According to Pamela Vander's instagram, MES liked her dog (or one they bought to together, or something).
dannyno
  • 49. dannyno | 22/06/2019
My concordance has "feet" not "streets", so I agree with that.
bzfgt
  • 50. bzfgt (link) | 29/06/2019
The things we do for love...
Fred
  • 51. Fred | 30/07/2020
I might be completely off here, but I've always interpreted the the lyrics from 'it was the fault of the government' secion to be at least partly about the Labour Party and some of its supporters at the time.

As a party member I've been to the Labour Conference many times and Jerusalem (the hymn) is occasionally sung and always following the Leaders Speech. A speech which would criticise the government for pretty much everything, and MES's verse could be seen as a direct parody of such a speech.

It seems really obvious to me - the silly blaming of the government for slipping on a banana skin, blaming the gov for not getting a million pounds in the budget and the lines "migrate to Sweden or Poland, And get looked after properly by government" - denoting a different, and socialist/social democratic government model, as would be advanced by Labour members.

I've not seen anything to show that MES ever went to a national Labour conference, but he has spoken about being a supporter of theirs until the Falklans Wars, and it's easy to imagine that he would be aware of the traditional singing of the hymn.

I don't think MEs is being explicitly anti-Labour in the song, but poking fun at the usage of Jerusalem at Party conferences and of the attitudes of some of its members/supporters.
dannyno
  • 52. dannyno | 31/08/2020
It was reasonably common knowledge that Jerusalem was/is something of a labour movement hymn, so Fred in comment #51 isn't making too much of a stretch in seeing a connection. Not for nothing are the collected works of Clement Attlee entitled The New Jerusalem - he made the poem the theme of Labour's 1945 election campaign.

I do quite like the connection, although I do find it notable that although MES said quite a bit about his motives with regard to this song, he never mentioned the Labour Party.

But the major, and ultimately sadly fatal, problem with linking Jerusalem to Labour Party conferences, in relation to a song debuted in 1988, is that apparently it wasn't sung at any Labour Party conference until 1990.

Whatever else we might think about the appropriateness of such a parody, I don't think it's plausible to suggest MES was parodying something that hadn't happened and wouldn't happen for another couple of years.

A few other factlets, though, showing that "Jerusalem" type rhetoric is not uncommon in the culture:

In the Guardian of 15 October 1988 (so well after the song was debuted), journalist Andrew Rawnsley's Tory party Brighton conference sketch appeared, under the title "Building a New Jerusalem at Nuremberg on Sea". It contains the line;


Mrs Thatcher advanced on to the stage, and the organist played Jerusalem, having temporarily misplaced God Save the Queen.


The Guardian of 27 May 1986 (so some time before the song was debuted) contains a commentary by Hugo Young on Thatcher's visit to Israel, headlined "When Mrs Thatcher sings of Jerusalem".
dannyno
  • 53. dannyno | 31/08/2020
Not just 1945: Attlee quoting Blake in 1951:

https://youtu.be/RNcX_t_AuVA
dannyno
  • 54. dannyno | 31/08/2020
Buggered up the link there:

bzfgt
  • 55. bzfgt (link) | 06/09/2020
I don't know much about the labour movement in Britain, I did read EP Thompson but it's been years...what do you think is the note I could/should extract from all this?
bzfgt
  • 56. bzfgt (link) | 06/09/2020
I don't mean you should compose the note, just give me some indication of what is noteworthy
Fred
  • 57. Fred | 10/09/2020
Excellent points by dannyno (52-54). as you say, ,my theory is killed off by the fact that Jerusalem was not sung at Labour Party conference until 1990. I did not know this and it's such a shame as I thought the connection perfect.
dannyno
  • 58. dannyno | 17/09/2020
Fred, comment #57.

Well, the specific connection you were making unfortunately falls, but you rightly drew attention to something that does need bringing out clearly in these notes. Blake's text, which of course reflects his own peculiar religio-political concerns, has been co-opted by 20th century politicians of both left and right.


I will not cease from Mental Fight,
Nor shall my Sword sleep in my hand:
Till we have built Jerusalem,
In Englands green & pleasant Land


For the left and the labour movement, "building Jerusalem" has a radical meaning; it's about establishing socialism. For the right, they see it in nationalistic and conservative terms.

Either way, this song ironically contrasts the transcendent utopianism of Blake's poem, and the petty whinging he hears in his local pub, or from fellow artists. Visionary politics has been replaced by nanny statism and self-interest and entitlement. Now it's not unreasonable to see that, in the context of the time, and given the "the government should look after me" content, and MES's frequently expressed anti-socialism (derived more from betrayals by socialists, perhaps, rather than a rejection of progressive working class politics per se, but who knows), as targeting the left. But it's not necessarily so - such sentiments are common across the spectrum.

Anyway, none of that is uniquely insightful. In terms of a note, I think it's just about flagging the irony and identifying Jerusalem's political meanings.
bzfgt
  • 59. bzfgt (link) | 20/09/2020
I just quoted your comment for now, and fixed some numbering...I think I've said this before but I've got to put some more work into this at some point
E-an
  • 60. E-an | 14/12/2020
'The middle bit I wrote a poem called system vanguard.' - the fall mark e. smith October 30 1988 Radio Lancashire
Ivan
  • 61. Ivan | 25/07/2021
Re: Dan's comment #42 about the timing of Mark's NME 'travel diary':

Holland

On arrival write vicious anti-dog rant, although I haven't seen one in ages. What actually sparks it off was hearing English cricket commentary on hotel's TV. This was depressing after bliss of six weeks of TV in foreign languages, where you can make it up yourself.

I was intrigued by that too. But I'd put it later in the year - on the trip to Holland in June, rather than the one in April. In the NME piece his entry about Holland follows the ones for USA and Vancouver (which were in May), and a travel diary would presumably follow chronological order.

Also, there are obvious candidates for the commentary source in June.

The first three performances of I Am Curious Orange were in Amsterdam from June 11th to 13th. That makes the likely candidates:

June 2nd-7th England v West Indies, First Test Match. Televised by the BBC.

June 8th Benson and Hedges Cup Semi-Final. Televised by the BBC.

There were two semi-finals on that day. It's not clear whether the BBC showed Essex v Hampshire or Derbyshire v Glamorgan. The weather in England must have been awful that week. Both games were left unfinished on Wednesday evening (they were supposed to be one day games). The Essex game finished the following day, while the game at Derby didn't finish until Friday 10th. It's not clear whether the BBC showed the game on the unscheduled Thursday (or Friday). (The Test Match had also been hit by the weather, and ended in a tame draw).

Why cricket commentary would trigger such anti-dog feeling is the question that this (ahem) begs. Was it just someone's voice annoying him? Or was it something more specific? Might there have been some reference to this English cricketer?

https://i.postimg.cc/RCRcfMmM/Jack-Russell.jpg

His name is Robert Charles Russell, known to all as 'Jack Russell'.

During the summer of 1988, the English Test selectors chose both Jack Russell and Paul Downton for the wicketkeeper's position. It was Downton who was playing in the June Test Match mentioned above, but it's easy to imagine the commentators discussing the relative merits of the two rivals. (Russell wouldn't have featured in those Benson and Hedges semi-finals - his county was Gloucestershire.

By the way, Mark wasn't the only Englishman with a hotel story that week. During that First Test Match, England captain Mike Gatting had secretly invited a barmaid, Louise Shipman, into his room at the Rothley Court Hotel in Leicestershire. The English tabloids quickly found out, and Gatting, who admitted taking Shipman to his room but denied that anything 'untoward' had happened, was sacked.
Ivan
  • 62. Ivan | 25/07/2021
Continued...

One thing that might question the timing I suggest above is the closeness to the premiere of I Am Curious Orange. Would they change the music so close to the opening of the show? Well, it seems that's the way Mark liked it:

Simon Ford write in Hip Priest that:

The Fall's almost constant touring throughout 1988 complicated the ballet's production. Songs were recorded on the road and sent back to Clark in London. The problem with this arrangement became immediately apparent at rehearsals, just a couple of weeks before the June premiere at the Stadsschouwburg in Amsterdam. The new songs had evolved as the tour progressed and therefore the versions that Clark had choreographed to were now out of date. Schofield volunteered to listen to Clark's tapes and reteach the band the older versions. 'This was the source of much friction', she recalled. 'I was seen as being very bossy. But I was torn between Michael's needs and The Fall's, who never did anything the same way two nights running. We had some major rows about that time. I think it was the first time I quit or Mark sacked me'.

Note the reference to 'rehearsals just a couple of weeks before the premiere' (presumably this means both the band and Clark's team). So when did the band arrive in Holland?

Go back a couple of weeks from June 11th and you get to May 28th. Well, they wouldn't have arrived that day as they played in California on 27th. So it was a little less than two weeks for the band - perhaps leave the States on the 28th, pop home for a day or two then head for Amsterdam? Then you have an arrival at the start of June, pointing to the Test Match starting on the 2nd being the trigger for the track.

So was the televised cricket match that sparked Mark's ire really in June, or the earlier trip to Holland in April (as Dan suggested?)

The things that pushed me towards June are

1) The absence of realistic possibilities in April for the commentary (Dan suggests Pakistan v West Indies or early season county matches, but I wouldn't think so (I checked just in case and found no candidates).

2) The chronology in the NME travel diary.

The latter you could perhaps explain away, the first seems more tricky.

There remains one thing I can't square though:

1) Mark saying he was sick to hear the English commentary after 'the bliss of six weeks of TV in foreign languages'.

Before June they'd been in the States and Canada. In April they'd been in Germany, Austria, Switzerland and Belgium (though only for three weeks).

There's problems with both theories.
dannyno
  • 63. dannyno | 14/08/2021
IvanT: that's a helpful reanalysis.

You are right that there are several problems with me placing the writing of Dog is Life in April, and on reflection I accept it's more likely to be closer to the start of the Orange run in the Netherlands in June.

June did seem a bit too close to the performance, and there's his "six weeks" comment (which could just be a joke about North America or just lack of precision) but you have the quote about last minute changes - and also of course it's essentially a spoken word thing, so doesn't come with the difficulties new music would have caused.

So yes, June looks more plausible.
Hickory C. McCay
  • 64. Hickory C. McCay | 16/11/2021
I always thought Dog Is Life was a pun on the phrase "God is dead".

Add a comment